Previously Published in The Messenger
This week, Suffolk’s ten town supervisors penned a bipartisan letter to Governor Kathy Hochul (D-Hamburg) urging her and germane State leaders to, essentially, be more realistic when it comes to what the municipalities can afford in the face of brutal, unfunded State mandates.
The towns account for varying percentages of the property tax dollar, but on average, it’s pennies on the dollar compared to school districts, for instance, which account for about 70% of the property tax bill.
And yet, the towns have the onus of providing essential services while also leveraging those funds as best as they can to not only offer recreation and quality-of-life add-ons, but to be able to settle debate when taxpayers routinely ask, “why exactly am I paying so much in taxes?”
The State, run exclusively by Democrats since 2019, has been on a goodie-bag bender. While we think that many of their social programs, safety nets, and ambitious pitches as of late – subsidized childcare, for example – are not ill-intentioned, they’re certainly ill-conceived when the bigger picture is consulted.
It all goes back to the classic adage: a government powerful enough to give you everything you want is powerful enough to take it all away. Fiscal liberals and many in Albany will argue that times are tough and the government needs to step up, when it has been, in fact, the state and federal governments’ fiscal malfeasance run amok for decades all along.
In other words, create the problem and present yourself as the solution, Albany ostensibly says.
We can’t find a good argument against decent benefits for municipal workers. After all, they do make the towns and vital services run, and there’s no reason a good collective bargaining agreement can’t remain in place, we think. But at the same time, if Albany wants to sweeten the pot to whatever end, they should understand that requiring the towns, who have many locked contracts in these areas, are being squeezed too thin. Either taxes must go exorbitantly, or services must be cut.
Even the best-budgeted town will face this problem as long as Albany continues on its spending rampage, which begs the question, why do the towns face the arbitrary tax caps while the State has free range and the Comptroller seems to have been reduced to a mere suggestion of good economic principles?
Comptroller Tom DiNapoli (D-Great Neck Plaza) has done a solid job over the years in calling balls and strikes and lambasting his own party on their reckless spending habits. Albany, however, never wants to be realistic and say, “give it to me straight, doc.”
It’s no question that both parties, at least federally, are on a spending binge to retain votes. In the State, we place more of that blame on the Democrats, but there are Republicans who are clearly petrified of rocking the boat in the face of political annihilation. But all we’re seeing is fiscal mismanagement, which increases the cost of living, followed by goodie-bag deals to keep people in New York, which is then followed by more fiscal mismanagement. It’s a brutal cycle and it seems there’s not an adult in the room to be found – obligatory reference to Assemblyman Michael Fitzpatrick (R-St. James) who has been sounding this alarm for decades.
In New York, the Democrats are invariably the party of giveaways. Again, we don’t think their ends are ill-intentioned, but the means are not justifying those ends. The townships shouldn’t be on the hook, not just fiscally, but also reputationally. They will now face the ire of their residents who see massive spikes in property tax bills and rightfully descend on Town Hall to complain.
Yet this year’s gubernatorial election might be more of a referendum on Donald Trump than their own qualities of life in New York, as disastrous a president as Trump is right now.
Suffolk County once again gets punished for voting against the State machine in the last several elections, while Albany will continue to pin the blame on the federal government.
This didn’t begin with Washington, D.C., or Donald Trump, and it certainly won’t end with them either.
We’re not endorsing Long Island statehood, for practical and logistical reasons – at least not right now – but we won’t be surprised if that’s a much more salient topic in the coming years.
