By Hank Russell
The New York State Democratic Committee has filed a complaint with the New York State Board of Elections (BOE) demanding that Bruce Blakeman’s gubernatorial campaign should not receive matching funds from the state “until every pending and previously paid claim has been independently verified.”
On October 7, Committee Chairman Jay S. Jacobs sent the complaint to the BOE urging the Public Campaign Finance Board (PCFB) to withhold the funding and called on the Division of Election Law Enforcement to investigate the Blakeman campaign’s disclosure filings. Jacobs cited a New York Focus article in the complaint which reported that Blakeman — the Nassau County executive who is running against incumbent Kathy Hochul — “requested public matching funds for more than 2,600 donations” totaling over $860,000 “that don’t qualify for the state’s campaign finance program,” according to the article.
Jacobs noted that it was reported that more than 200 one-dollar donations came from out of state, making them ineligible for matching funds. He said that a Blakeman campaign spokesperson “insisted to the New York Focus that the errors had been corrected through amended reports, yet the most recent versions of the campaign’s amended reports still include match requests for thousands of ineligible contributions. … Not only did the Blakeman campaign lie to the people of the State of New York and the Board of Elections, they then misled the press.”
The chairman also cited a Newsday report which “bolsters these concerns,” adding, “The campaign’s newest disclosure report appears to double- or triple-count thousands of individual contributions. Newsday found the same donor recorded as making the same contribution two or three times on the same day, with the possible repeats totaling more than $460,000. A single matchable $250 contribution generates $1,500 in public money, and a contribution entered three times could generate an additional $3,000 if the duplication were not caught.”
The PCFB “has the tools” to look into Blakeman’s campaign filing records and “‘may at any time audit any participating candidate for which it receives credible reports involving potential campaign-related fraud, knowing and willful violations of this article, or criminal activity’ related to the receipt or use of program funds; it must recover any payment in excess of what a candidate was eligible to receive; and the candidate and committee are jointly and severally liable for such repayments.”
Both the NYS Democrats and the Hochul campaign also made an issue of Blakeman’s finances. As previously reported in Long Island Life & Politics, Blakeman’s campaign has only $178,000 in the bank going into this month. It is “the smallest balance for any major-party gubernatorial candidate in the state this century,” according to an article from PoliticoPro. The Hochul campaign, meanwhile, ended last month’s filing period with more than $18.5 million cash on hand.
“The public matching funds program was created to amplify the voices of New York donors, not to underwrite a campaign’s inability, or unwillingness, to follow its most basic rules,” Jacobs said. “New Yorkers are entitled to know that their tax dollars are being paid out only on contributions that actually qualify. Election Day is less than four weeks away. Once these dollars go out the door, they will be spent, and they will not come back.”
LILP reached out to the Blakeman campaign for a response.
“Kathy Hochul already tried to illegally block our matching funds once, and a judge stopped her,” said Blakeman campaign spokesperson Madison Spanodemos. “Now, with our ads exposing her tax and utility hikes, she’s trying again. She knows she’s in trouble, and this desperate attempt won’t save her.”
